The Brewers’ Five Greatest Pitchers

Number one

Ted Higuera (1985-94)
Five years after Fernandomania swept the baseball world, Higuera—a fellow Mexican native whose middle name, ironically, was Valenzuela—failed to engender the same publicity, but he was beloved in Milwaukee, where he was arguably the American League’s top left-handed pitcher in the late 1980s.

Higuera impressed during the early 1980s in the Mexican leagues, and signed on with the Brewers for 1984; after a year in the minors, he had a solid 15-8 rookie campaign in 1985 and improved further the next year by becoming only the second Mexican in major league history—and the last Brewer to date—to nab 20 wins in a season, just three days after Valenzuela had beaten him to the punch. The effort placed Higuera second in the 1986 AL Cy Young Award vote, behind Roger Clemens.

Throughout the rest of the decade, Higuera would retain his ace status in the Milwaukee rotation, finishing 18-10 in 1987 and 16-9 (with a career-low 2.45 earned run average) in 1988, thus becoming the only Brewer pitcher to win at least 15 games in four straight seasons. His 3.61 career ERA is the best in franchise history among starting pitchers.

Higuera’s downfall came early in 1991 when his rotator cuff became unhinged, missing nearly three full years as a result. A comeback attempt fell completely flat.

Number two

Mike Caldwell (1977-84)
For six years in the National League, Caldwell bounced around three teams as a model of frustration, with stretches of promise constantly interrupted by elbow problems. Even his first half-season with the Brewers, after a trade from Cincinnati in 1977, showed little sign of progress—or hope. Then came 1978.

Showing off a new slider, Caldwell broke out with blindsiding success—posting a 22-9 record and 2.36 ERA in a prodigious 293.1 innings; he led the AL with 23 complete games, shut out the World Series-bound New York Yankees three times and finished second in the AL Cy Young vote. Hitters complained he was too good to be true, with multiple accusations that his slider was, in fact, a spitter.

Over the next five years, Caldwell never duplicated the success of 1978 but remained a solid factor in the rotation, winning 69 games; for the 1982 AL champion Brewers, he won 17 and received credit for two of the team’s three wins in the seven-game World Series loss to St. Louis, throwing one complete game and coming within one out of another.

Number three

Rollie Fingers (1981-85)
Best remembered as the closer with the quintessential mustache for the world champion Oakland A’s of the early 1970s, Fingers gave Milwaukee baseball fans some of their happiest memories with his short but sweet stint as a Brewer during the early 1980s.

Of Fingers’ 17 years as a major leaguer, none was better than his 1981 debut with the Brewers. In a season cut in third by the players’ strike, Fingers led the AL with 28 saves and produced a miniscule 1.04 ERA, lifting the team to its first-ever postseason berth while becoming the first reliever to win both the MVP and Cy Young awards in the same season.

Fingers was in the midst of another solid campaign in 1982 when a September elbow injury sidelined him for the rest of the year—and all of 1983 to boot; his absence from the 1982 World Series possibly cost the Brewers, whose bullpen produced a shoddy 5.54 ERA in his absence as St. Louis won in seven games. Back in action in 1984, another excellent campaign (1.96 ERA, 23 saves) came to a screeching halt in late July when he hurt his back, shelving him again for the rest of the year. Fingers’ career came to an end a year later after a substandard (1-6, 5.04 ERA) campaign.

Bushers Book
Number four

Pete Vuckovich (1981-86)
A big, wild-eyed roughneck with a last name to match, Vuckovich came from St. Louis with Fingers and Ted Simmons in a seven-player deal that helped mold the postseason Brewers of the early 1980s—and ignited his brief but fantastic run that culminated with the 1982 AL Cy Young award.

From 1981-82, Vuckovich compiled an excellent 32-10 record—though his other numbers were not reflective of a stifling dominance. Even in his award-winning 1982 campaign, Vuckovich nearly walked as many batters (102) as he struck out. Yet he held the knack to win, running his record to 18-4 in 1982; but after throwing 163 pitches in an 11-inning game late in September, he was 0-4 (postseason included) for the rest of the year, and such woe may have been connected to a rotator cuff injury early in 1983 that would cause him to miss nearly two years.

Vuckovich was very expressive on the mound, loaded with offbeat mannerisms that made him a more psychotic version of Mark Fidrych. Teammate Lary Sorensen once claimed, perhaps jokingly, that Vuckovich ate nails and glass and swallowed live toads. His brute size and demeanor led him to be cast as the opposing, brute Yankee heavy Clu Heywood in the 1989 film Major League; as a pitching coach for the Pittsburgh Pirates from 1997-2000, Vuckovich continued to show his penchant for abrasive attention by being thrown out of 11 games.

Number five

Yovani Gallardo (2007-2014, 2018)
Two decades after Higuera, the Brewers witnessed another Mexican native emerge as the team’s top pitcher in Gallardo, who produced a sturdy succession of solid campaigns in Milwaukee.

Called up to replace an injured Chris Capuano in June 2007, Gallardo answered with a 9-5 record and 3.67 ERA in barely half a season to stake his claim on the Brewers rotation. A knee injury stripped him of activity for the majority of the 2008 campaign, but he stayed healthy afterwards—producing five straight winning seasons with impressively steady strikeout and ERA figures. Though he only won one of five postseason appearances for the Brewers, he did so with a fine 2.08 ERA.

Gallardo also possessed one of the game’s best power strokes among pitchers, belting 12 home runs in 362 career at-bats for Milwaukee; he was the only pitcher ever to homer off Randy Johnson to win a 1-0 duel for the Brewers in 2009—making him only the third pitcher in history to throw a shutout, strike out at least 10 and go deep for the only run of the game.

Milwaukee Brewers Team History: Year-by year records, statistics and an oral history of the Brewers, decade by decade.

The Brewers' Five Greatest Hitters: A list of the five greatest hitters based on their productivity and efficiency.

The Brewers' Five Greatest Games: A list of five memorable games and other notable personal achievements that have defined the Brewers' history.

How did This Great Game determine the list of the Brewers' five greatest pitchers? Find out here.

share this page with a friendShare this page with a friend.

Have a comment, question or request? Contact us at This Great Game.

© 2019 This Great Game.

All-Time Brewers Pitching Leaders

Jim Slaton
Mike Caldwell
Ted Higuera
Moose Haas
Yovani Gallardo

Earned Run Average
Dan Plesac
Chuck Crim
Ted Higuera
Jim Colburn
Yovani Gallardo

Winning Percentage
Pete Vuckovich
Ted Higuera
Yovani Gallardo
Mike Caldwell
Moose Haas

Complete Games
Mike Caldwell
Jim Slaton
Moose Haas
Jim Colburn
Ted Higuera, Lary Sorensen

Jim Slaton
Mike Caldwell
Ted Higuera
Bill Travers
Moose Haas, Chris Bosio

Dan Plesac
Jim Slaton
Bob McClure
Chuck Crim
Mike Fetters

Jim Slaton
Mike Caldwell
Moose Haas
Bill Wegman
Ben Sheets

Yovani Gallardo
Ben Sheets
Ted Higuera
Jim Slaton
Moose Haas

Dan Plesac
John Axford
Rollie Fingers
Francisco Rodriguez
Mike Fetters, Bob Wickman

All statistics are through the 2018 season. Earned run average (ERA) and winning percentage leaders are based on players with 500 or more innings. Bold type indicates active Brewers player.