The Yearly Reader

Leaders and Honors, 1919

Our list of baseball’s top 10 hitters and pitchers in both the American League and National League for the 1919 baseball season, as well as the awards and honors given to the game’s top achievers of the year.

The National League’s Top 10 Hitters, 1919

Bold type in brick red indicates league leader.

1. George Burns, New York

Key Numbers: .303 average, 86 runs, 30 doubles, 9 triples, 82 walks, 40 stolen bases, .396 on-base percentage.

Burns used more than his bat to rankle pitchers, leading the NL in walks and steals.

2. Edd Roush, Cincinnati

Key Numbers: .321 average, 19 doubles, 12 triples, 71 RBIs.

Roush’s average may have been the NL’s best, but it was his personal worst between 1917-26.

3. Heinie Groh, Cincinnati

Key Numbers: .310 average, 79 runs, 17 doubles, 11 triples, 56 walks.

Roush’s prime equal in the Reds lineup was in the top five of most NL offensive categories—but he failed to place first in any of them.

4. Rogers Hornsby, St. Louis

Key Numbers: .318 average, 163 hits, 9 triples, 8 home runs, 71 RBIs.

The Rajah collected nearly half of the Cardinals’ total home run output (18).

5. Ross Youngs, New York

Key Numbers: .311 average, 31 doubles, 7 triples.

The compact, aggressive and quiet Youngs—a favorite pet of John McGraw—began to make an impact for the Giants at age 22.

6. Benny Kauff, New York

Key Numbers: .277 average, 27 doubles, 7 triples, 10 home runs, 67 RBIs.

The last rodeo at the top for the former Federal League star; within a year he’d be dogged by auto theft charges and his involvement in the Black Sox Scandal.

7. Hi Myers, Brooklyn

Key Numbers: .307 average, 23 doubles, 14 triples, 73 RBIs, .436 slugging percentage.

Myers’ RBI total and slugging percentage were both the lowest ever by a modern-day NL leader.

8. Zack Wheat, Brooklyn

Key Numbers: .297 average, 23 doubles, 11 triples, 5 home runs, 62 RBIs, 15 stolen bases.

At age 31, Wheat was given the captainship of the Robins and responded with one of his more productive Deadball Era campaigns; the coming live ball would catapult his statistical game even more.

9. Larry Doyle, New York

Key Numbers: 113 games, .289 average, 10 triples, 7 home runs, 52 RBIs, 12 stolen bases.

In his penultimate season, the 33-year-old Giants captain gave a solid renaissance after a couple of relatively mediocre seasons.

10. Irish Meusel, Philadelphia

Key Numbers: .305 average, 26 doubles, 7 triples, 5 home runs, 59 RBIs, 24 stolen bases.

Before the live ball aided his game, Meusel was given a boost from his home ballpark (Baker Bowl) where he hit .368, while only posting a .238 figure on the road.

The American League’s Top 10 Hitters, 1919

1. Babe Ruth, Boston

Key Numbers: .322 average, 103 runs, 34 doubles, 12 triples, 29 home runs, 113 RBIs, 101 walks, .456 on-base percentage, .657 slugging percentage.

The Bambino gave the Red Sox a fleeting taste of what they were going to miss over the next 15 years.

2. Bobby Veach, Detroit

Key Numbers: .355 average, 87 runs, 191 hits, 45 doubles, 17 triples, 3 home runs, 101 RBIs.

Banner year for the star outfielder with career highs in batting average, hits, doubles and triples.

3. George Sisler, St. Louis

Key Numbers: .352 average, 96 runs, 180 hits, 31 doubles, 15 triples, 10 home runs, 83 RBIs, 28 stolen bases.

Sisler hit at least .340 for the third straight year to round out the Deadball Era; that would be nothing compared to what he had in store for the next three seasons.

4. Ty Cobb, Detroit

Key Numbers: .384 average, 92 runs, 191 hits, 36 doubles, 13 triples, 28 stolen bases.

The Georgia Peach won the last of his 12 batting crowns, but his best years were hardly behind him.

5. Joe Jackson, Chicago

Key Numbers: .351 average, 181 hits, 31 doubles, 14 triples, 7 home runs, 96 RBIs.

Shoeless Joe returned to early-career form by hitting on the north side of .350, but it was mere prologue to the fateful events of the ensuing World Series.

6. Eddie Collins, Chicago

Key Numbers: .319 average, 87 runs, 4 home runs, 80 RBIs, 68 walks, 33 stolen bases.

Unlike Jackson, Collins was not part of the Black Sox cabal but he too had one of his stronger years in recent times.

7. Harry Heilmann, Detroit

Key Numbers: .320 average, 74 runs, 30 doubles, 15 triples, 8 home runs, 93 RBIs.

The Tigers skipped nary a beat with the loss of retired Sam Crawford, as the equally talented Heilmann took over.

8. Tris Speaker, Cleveland

Key Numbers: .296 average, 83 runs, 38 doubles, 12 triples, 73 walks.

Perhaps adjusting to a mid-season inheriting of the Indians’ manager position, Speaker batted below .300 for the only time outside of his first and last years.

9. Sam Rice, Washington

Key Numbers: 141 games, .321 average, 179 hits, 23 doubles, 9 triples, 26 stolen bases.

After serving the military in 1918—ultimately costing him a shot at 3,000 hits—Rice returned to Washington and resumed his early stellar form.

10. Happy Felsch, Chicago

Key Numbers: .275 average, 34 doubles, 11 triples, 7 home runs, 86 RBIs, 19 stolen bases.

No White Sox player hit more home runs during the 1910s than the 24—yes, 24—collected by Felsch, who hit seven in 1919 alone.

Bushers Book Ad

The National League’s Top 10 Pitchers, 1919

1. Babe Adams, Pittsburgh

Key Numbers: 1.98 ERA, 17 wins, 10 losses, 263.1 innings, 23 walks.

All but forgotten after a two-year absence, Adams marveled anew at age 37—and for the first of three straight years would be the NL’s toughest pitcher to reach base against.

2. Hippo Vaughn, Chicago

Key Numbers: 1.79 ERA, 21 wins, 14 losses, 37 starts, 306.2 innings, 141 strikeouts.

Vaughn retained his standing as NL workhorse; if not again for a shortened (140 games) schedule, his innings total would have been all the more impressive.

3. Pete Alexander, Chicago

Key Numbers: 1.72 ERA, 16 wins, 11 losses, 9 shutouts.

Though his traumatizing front-line duty during the Great War may have changed the great ace off the mound, it didn’t seem to affect him while he was on it as he grabbed his third ERA crown.

4. Slim Sallee, Cincinnati

Key Numbers: 2.06 ERA, 21 wins 7 losses.

So homesick that he refused to return to the Giants, Sallee was granted a trade closer to his Ohio home with the Reds and responded with his best effort at age 34.

5. Jesse Barnes, New York

Key Numbers: 2.40 ERA, 25 wins, 9 losses, 295.2 innings.

The Giants beat the Yankees and Red Sox to the punch in initiating a one-sided Boston-to-New York pipeline, as former Braves pitcher and 25-game winner Barnes proved.

6. Phil Douglas, Cincinnati-New York

Key Numbers: 2.03 ERA, 12 wins, 10 losses.

The unpredictable, alcohol-inclined talent pitched well for both the Reds and Giants, but his trade to New York was one that Giants manager John McGraw likely would come to regret.

7. Dutch Ruether, Cincinnati

Key Numbers: 1.82 ERA, 19 wins, 6 losses, .760 win percentage.

The southpaw’s first full season would be his best; all but one of his wins would come after the end of May.

8. Wilbur Cooper, Pittsburgh

Key Numbers: 2.67 ERA, 19 wins, 13 losses, 27 complete games, 286.2 innings, 15 hit-by-pitches.

Cooper settled for 19 wins for the second straight year after losing each of his last three starts; he made sure that would never happen again.

9. Hal Carlson, Pittsburgh

Key Numbers: 2.23 ERA, 8 wins, 10 losses.

A mixed bag of sorts for a pitcher who tolerating a yo-yo career, as he was unable to translate a career-best ERA into a winning record.

10. Hod Eller, Cincinnati

Key Numbers: 2.39 ERA, 19 wins, 9 losses, 248.1 innings.

Eller’s career peaked because the rules made him; the shineballer would not be given the same “grandfather” leniency as spitball artists starting in 1920.

The American League’s Top 10 Pitchers, 1919

1. Eddie Cicotte, Chicago

Key Numbers: 1.82 ERA, 29 wins, 7 losses, 30 complete games, .806 win percentage, 306.2 innings.

Fixing the World Series notwithstanding, Cicotte’s emotions were yo-yo-ing enough, leading the AL in wins one year (1917), in losses the next (1918) and in wins again during 1919.

2. Walter Johnson, Washington

Key Numbers: 1.49 ERA, 20 wins, 14 losses, 7 shutouts, 290.1 innings, 147 strikeouts.

The Decade of Walter concluded with the Big Train winning his fourth ERA title, his ninth strikeout crown (and eighth in succession), and with a win in his final start ensured that he would win 20 or more games every year during the 1910s.

3. Lefty Williams, Chicago

Key Numbers: 2.64 ERA, 23 wins, 11 losses, 40 starts, 297 innings, 11 hit-by-pitches.

The first of two consecutive 20-win campaigns for the young southpaw; there may have been more such results in his future—but because of the Black Sox Scandal, we’ll never know.

4. Stan Coveleski, Cleveland

Key Numbers: 2.61 ERA, 24 wins, 12 losses, 286 innings.

The Cleveland ace consistently carried on, racking up another 20-plus wins.

5. Carl Mays, Boston-New York

Key Numbers: 2.10 ERA, 14 wins, 14 losses, 266 innings.

Despite his house burning down, run-ins with fans and a demand for a trade from Boston—which he got—Mays managed to stay focused on the mound.

6. Bob Shawkey, New York

Key Numbers: 2.72 ERA, 20 wins, 11 losses, 5 saves, 261.1 innings.

The veteran pitcher who experienced the best and worst of times earlier in the decade with the A’s was enjoying high times in New York; he was particularly good at the Polo Grounds (the Yankees’ home until 1923), where he posted a 12-1 record.

7. Carl Weilman, St. Louis

Key Numbers: 2.07 ERA, 10 wins, 6 losses.

A rare, if limited, winning year for the veteran lefty who struggled for support earlier in the decade.

8. Jim Shaw, Washington

Key Numbers: 2.73 ERA, 17 wins, 17 losses, 5 saves, 45 appearances, 306.2 innings, 10 wild pitches.

Walter Johnson may have remained the Washington ace, but Shaw could officially claim the title of team workhorse—becoming the first Senator besides Johnson to lead the team in innings pitched since 1908.

9. Allen Sothoron, St. Louis

Key Numbers: 2.20 ERA, 20 wins, 13 losses, 270 innings.

Sothoron, who like Eddie Cicotte once led the AL with 19 losses (in 1917), also enjoyed his finest year; he couldn’t maintain his excellence going forward even as he was allowed to continue throwing the spitter after 1920.

10. Jack Quinn, New York

Key Numbers: 2.61 ERA, 15 wins, 14 losses, 266 innings.

Back in New York City after seven years wandering about elsewhere, Quinn put together a solid effort at age 36; little did anyone realize that he’d be sticking around for quite a while.

1919 Baseball History
The 1910s: The Feds, the Fight and the Fix
TGG Lists: The 10 Best Pitchers of the 1910s
TGG Lists: The 10 Best Hitters of the 1910s